This week’s topic is a freebie, so I decided to come up with my own. I’m thinking back over books that, for one reason or another, I didn’t expect to like going in, but that I really, really did. Either they’re a genre I don’t usually enjoy, an author I didn’t get along with previously, I’d heard some negative reviews of them, or I had to read them for some reason. But in spite of the strike they had against them, I ended up loving them. Who knows – maybe you would too!
I don’t normally like books about post-apocalyptic situations or zombie type creatures. But somehow The Girl with All the Gifts had so much heart and was told with such great pacing that I couldn’t help but love it. I’m not normally into Sci-Fi or Fantasy either, so the next two I shouldn’t have loved. But The Martian was so brilliantly plotted and wonderfully humorous that I had an immensely great time reading it (I recently re-read it as an audiobook and had just as much fun as the first time). Spinning Silver I never would have picked up on my own, but one of my best friends, Scott, sent it to me, swearing up and down that I’d love it. And guess what? I totally did. It’s brilliant, impossible to put down once you’re immersed, and full of great (strong, mostly female) characters. I nearly chickened out on The Pull of the Stars. Not because of the book itself, but because of the context. It’s set during the Spanish Influenza pandemic of 1918, and seeing as we’re currently in the middle of a similarly terrifying and deadly pandemic, I didn’t know if I could handle it on the page and in real life. I started it tentatively, but next thing I knew it was halfway done and I had no desire to pause listening, let along put it down. I loved the characters, and there are some great underlying themes (women’s rights, the lack of compassionate care in medicine, LGBTQ2IAP+ romance).
I mean, Ducks, Newburyport is a beast. It’s nearly 1,000 pages long, and almost the entirety of that massive page count is stream of consciousness without any punctuation. It’s daunting, to say the least. I had such a hard time getting into it. I tried several times. I then got it in my BookTube Prize round (because of course I did), and had no choice. I downloaded the audiobook, cranked the speed up to double, and lo and behold, I got completely into it. I listened while cooking dinner, while tidying up the house, while scrubbing the bathtub, while plotting activities to keep my bored kid occupied over the next week. It turned out to be not only a fantastic book, but brilliant company. The narrator is so smart, yet her life belies that intelligence. It’s so easy to assume housewives and stay-at-home mums are dull somehow. That they’re doing that because of a lack of other prospects or talents. But that’s not at all the case. This one is well-traveled, well-read, has searing and prescient opinions on society (she even sees the pandemic coming) and is someone I’d love to be friends with. I’m not going to say everyone should read it. But if you are interested in it, well versed in audiobooks and would like to experience a little bit of what happens inside a stay-at-home mum’s head, give it a try. Shuggie Bain is another I had in my BookTube round this year, and though I already had it on my shelf, I found it a bit dark and hard to get into. But I’m so glad I ended up being forced to give it a fair shake, because it’s well worth the effort. Hamnet is historical fiction (not set during WWII, the only historical period I’m regularly drawn to), about yet another pandemic, and a fictionalized account of Shakespeare’s family. None of which particularly appealed to me. And yet… the writing drew me in and held on, and I was so glad I gave it a try (thanks Mum!). I’ve not always gotten on that well with Joan Didion. I’ve liked some of her work, admired her courage in sharing emotionally devastating themes in others, but I’ve also had issues with her dismissal of privilege and seemingly willfully naïve view of life. But this book had a more sharp and critical tone, almost tongue-in-cheek and poking fun at times. It’s got funny moments, and also makes some comments that seem prescient from this side of history. It’s short and punchy and well worth checking out, whether you’re a Didion fan or not.
City of Girls is another I had to read for BookTube prize judging in 2020. I had tried reading Eat, Pray, Love and really didn’t get on with it. I had no patience for a White woman whose marriage falls apart and she jets off to spend months traveling to “find herself” and experience food, spirituality and, presumably a fling or two (I gave up on it somewhere around Italian food so I don’t know how it ended). Who does that and then writes a “poor me” book about it? Seriously, who? Most of us can’t even take a break to deal with physical illness, nevermind heartbreak. I’m not trying to minimize her suffering – the failure of a marriage sucks and can cause severe mental health issues. But the whole premise of the book just didn’t appeal to me personally. (A note: I have heard others review this and say that the tone of the book seems more self-aware than I picked up, and can actually poke fun at that privilege that so irked me. I haven’t wanted to re-read it to re-assess, so it’s very possible my view is unfair. It’s just the feeling I had at the time.) So I decided to part ways with Elizabeth Gilbert. I wished her well on her own journey, but had no desire to spend any part of it with her. But this book ended up being so enjoyable and had a depth I didn’t expect. It entertained me and kept me happily flipping pages. She has redeemed herself. Now, I read Circe because it was on the shortlist for the Women’s Prize for Fiction, and I had decided to try and read the entire list. I’m not into mythology. Like, at all. But I read it, and you know what? I actually enjoyed it. It hasn’t changed my stance on mythology (I also read The Silence of the Girls for the same list, and it was okay, but I didn’t love it), but I’m glad I had an opportunity to give it a go. Daisy Jones and the Six is an odd one for this list. I went into it only having heard great things. I was at least somewhat interested in the premise. I’d heard good things about Taylor Jenkins Reid’s other books. My hesitation was wondering if it would be too much like some of the overly dramatic fiction I’ve read that ends up feeling like a reality show, and not in a good way. But man, this blew me away. The format was original, the characters were complex and flawed, the story had some great twists and turns, and I had no idea where it was going. It still isn’t a book I feel like I should like, and yet I absolutely do.
Okay, that’s it for me this week! I’d love to hear from you guys. Have you read any books that you didn’t expect to like but ended up loving? Have you read any of the ones on my list this week?
Top Ten Tuesday is a weekly link-up feature created by The Broke and the Bookish and hosted by Jana at That Artsy Reader Girl. Every week TTT has a different topic, and everyone who links up has to create a link of ten items that fit that topic. To see past and upcoming topics, go here.
The Girl with All the Gifts was such a pleasant surprise. I even enjoyed the movie adaption as well. 🙂
Oooh! Thanks for the recommendation! I have not yet watched it.
I really enjoyed Circe, but I’m a lot more into mythology than it sounds like you are! I’m glad you enjoyed all these more than you expected.
My TTT: https://jjbookblog.wordpress.com/2021/09/28/top-ten-tuesday-335/
I just never managed to get into mythology. I had brief brushes with it… but it never too hold! I am glad I did give Circe a try, though. Have you read her other book?
Fair enough! I have yes, I didn’t enjoy it as much as Circe though.
Good to know! It didn’t appeal to me as much, either.
Nice list! I like the sound of Spinning Silver. Here is my Top Ten Tuesday. Thank you!
I’d highly recommend giving it a try. It was so good!
Great post! I may go back and try some of these based on your comments. I LOVED Daisy Jones on audio!
Yay! I hope you find something else you enjoy. I tried Daisy as an audiobook, but I found it a little confusing. I think if I’d given it a bit longer I would have loved it as well, though – talk about an all-star cast! I am looking forward to the show.
Oh, great topic idea! I felt a bit hesitant about The Martian too, I remember, and ended up loving it.
I had the exact same experience with Project Hail Mary, too. Also loved it! Thanks to a few recs I got in my comments! Very glad I gave that one a try as well. Might be worth taking a look at it, if you haven’t already! I feel like if you loved The Martian, there’s a decent chance you’d love it too.
I’ve seen Shuggie Bain a few times and I am so curious, but also afraid to pick it up. It seems like such a heavy topic, and at the moment my head and heart can’t handle heavy.
Pam @ Read! Bake! Create!
https://readbakecreate.com/10-indigenous-authors-to-read/
You know, I felt exactly the same way. I’m not going to lie, it is heavy. Definitely. But the overwhelming feeling I ended up holding onto from it a few months on was love. Yes, the mum in it is a total mess. But the love Shuggie holds is amazing. I wouldn’t pick it up now, though, if you’re feeling fragile. It’s a lot. But one day, if it does speak to you, it might be worth a try!
Circe and Hamnet are two books that I found to be amazing reads which I didn’t expect to take to.
Me too! I was very meh about both of them. But they both ended up making a huge impression on me!
I loved The Martian and The Pull of the Stars!
My post: https://lydiaschoch.com/top-ten-tuesday-ten-ttt-topics-i-really-enjoyed-doing/
Me too! I was so glad I tried both of them. I was extra surprised that, given the current situation, I didn’t find The Pull of the Stars to be too hard. It was so beautiful.
Happy Tuesday! Naomi Novik’s books always reel me. Out of her new fairytale retellings book series, I really enjoyed Uprooted which was a Beauty & the Beast retelling.
Ducks, Newburyport still scares me because of how big it is.
If you have a chance I would love for you to check out my Top Tuesday post:
https://introvertinterruptedcom.wordpress.com/2021/09/28/books-that-got-me-through-my-20s-pt-2/
Have a good week!
I have Uprooted on my library holds list, so it’s good to know it’s worth picking up! Yeah, Ducks is a BEAST. I don’t think it will be worth it for everyone. If I hadn’t been reading it for a prize, I’m not sure if I would have gotten through it. I did, though, thanks to an audiobook on 2x speed, and I’m really glad I did. But I think at least part of the appeal was that I really connected to the main character of the book. Lacking that, it is a bit much! I loved how different it was, and it’s not a book I’ll ever read anything else like. So it has that going for it.
You may just have convinced me to give The Martian and Shuggie Bain a go 😁
Yay! The Martian does have a lot of sciencey discussion in it. But I have no science background and followed it easily, and because I like puzzle solving, I found that to be part of the appeal. And it’s just so funny! Shuggie Bain is deeply moving. It takes work, and emotional input, but it’s well worth it if you can handle it!
I too didn’t expect to like The Martian, and was surprised to find I loved it. I expected to like Hamnet but was disappointed, mainly because it is written in the third person present tense which distracted and distanced me from the story, although it is richly descriptive.
I don’t even remember the tense it was written in. I do remember finding it a bit difficult in the very beginning, but for me the rich setting and character development drew me in. I can see how it might not work for everyone though! I think a big part of it for me, too, was that I has such low expectations!
I’m seeing several titles here that I read and loved and other such as Hamnet and Shuggie Bain that are on my TBR. Happy reading! https://readwithstefani.com/ten-books-about-books/
Hamnet and Shuggie seem to be really appealing to a lot of people! Which ones did you enjoy most?
I really need to read Hamnet, and I too loved Circe! It’s always a joy to come across a book that you don’t expect to like and you love it. It just proves that some times it is good to take a chance. Oh, and I have no interest in reading Eat Pray Love but I loved Signature of All Things
I so agree! I often find that loving a book I had no expectations for is even better than loving one I predicted I’d enjoy. There’s something extra special about that!